News

The Percentage Mistakes That Quietly Mislead Small Business Owners

By
BizAge Interview Team
By

Most founders I speak to can recite their headline growth number without thinking. Sales up 40 per cent. Margin up three. Customer base doubled. Ask how that number was worked out, though, and the answers get vaguer. Sometimes it came from the accountant. Sometimes from a dashboard nobody has checked since it was set up. Quite often it was done in someone's head on the way into a meeting.

That matters more than it sounds. A percentage is a compressed story about your business, and if the arithmetic behind it is shaky, the decisions built on top of it will be too. You hire on it, borrow on it, set prices with it and pitch investors with it. Here are the mistakes I see most often, and they are by no means confined to first-time founders.

Dividing by the wrong number

The basic formula is not complicated: take the new figure, subtract the old one, divide by the old one, multiply by 100. If revenue goes from £80,000 to £100,000, that is a £20,000 increase on an £80,000 base, which is 25 per cent.

The trouble is that people divide by the wrong figure. Divide £20,000 by £100,000 and you get 20 per cent, a number that sounds perfectly plausible and is simply wrong. It is the most common slip of all, and it always errs the same way: it understates growth and exaggerates declines.

If you are unsure, work it backwards. £80,000 multiplied by 1.25 is £100,000. If the reverse sum doesn't land on your new figure, the percentage is wrong. For anything heading into a board pack or a funding deck, I would rather people ran it through a dedicated Percentage Increase Calculator than trusted a formula someone typed into a spreadsheet three years ago and never looked at again. It takes a few seconds and ends the argument before it starts.

Ups and downs don't cancel out

A retailer has a dreadful quarter and sales drop 20 per cent. The next quarter they bounce back by 20 per cent. Back where they started? Not quite. £100,000 falls to £80,000, and a 20 per cent rise on £80,000 takes you to £96,000. You are still £4,000 short.

To get from £80,000 back to £100,000 you need a 25 per cent increase. The deeper the fall, the steeper the climb: a business that loses half its revenue has to double it just to stand still. That is worth understanding before you tell staff, or your bank, that "we'll make it back next quarter".

Percentage points are not percentages

If your gross margin moves from 30 per cent to 33 per cent, it has gone up by three percentage points. It has also gone up by 10 per cent. Both statements are true and describe the same change, but they are not interchangeable.

People tend to pick whichever sounds better. A three-point rise in conversion rate sounds modest. "Conversion up 50 per cent", from 6 to 9 per cent, sounds like a breakthrough. Neither is dishonest on its own, but mixing the two in one report is how a management team ends up arguing about figures that actually agree with each other. Choose one convention and label it clearly.

Markup is not margin

This one costs real money. A product costs you £60 and you want a 40 per cent margin. Add 40 per cent to £60 and you get £84, but your margin on £84 is only £24, roughly 28.6 per cent. What you have applied is a 40 per cent markup. For a genuine 40 per cent margin you need to charge £100, which is £60 divided by 0.6.

I have met owners who ran for years believing they were making one margin when they were making another, and could never work out why the bank balance didn't match the plan. Markup is calculated on cost. Margin is calculated on the selling price. Write it on a sticky note if you have to.

Small bases make big headlines

"Revenue up 300 per cent" is a lovely line for a press release. It is also what happens when you go from £5,000 to £20,000. Early-stage growth rates are naturally enormous because the starting point is tiny, and they will fall as the company grows, even if it is doing brilliantly.

Investors know this, so a big percentage rarely impresses them on its own. Show the absolute figures alongside it. A 15 per cent rise on £2 million is £300,000 of new revenue, which tells a reader far more than a dramatic percentage on a small base.

Forgetting inflation

If your prices went up 8 per cent last year and your costs went up 10 per cent, you did not grow. You went backwards. The same goes for turnover: a 5 per cent rise in a year when prices across your sector rose by 6 per cent means you are selling less, not more.

The comparison that counts is real growth, after inflation. It is less flattering, which is exactly why it is worth looking at. It is also the right lens when the annual increase letter from a supplier or landlord lands on the mat: is that 7 per cent rise above or below what everyone else is facing?

Averaging growth rates

Say revenue rose 50 per cent in year one and fell 30 per cent in year two. The simple average is 10 per cent a year, which sounds respectable. But £100,000 becomes £150,000 and then £105,000. Over two years you have grown 5 per cent in total, or about 2.5 per cent a year.

When you want an annual figure across several years, use the compound annual growth rate rather than averaging the yearly numbers. It answers the question people actually mean: what steady rate would have taken me from where I started to where I am now?

Why it is worth getting right

None of this is advanced maths. It is the sort of thing most of us were taught at school and promptly forgot. But the cost of getting it wrong is anything but academic. A price rise meant to protect margin doesn't. A recovery plan assumes a bounce that never quite closes the gap. A pitch deck claims a growth rate that an investor's analyst recalculates in half a minute, and the founder's credibility takes a knock it never fully recovers from.

The fix is mostly habit. Write down the old figure and the new one, not just the percentage. Say which base you used. Keep percentage points and percentage change apart. Check margins against selling price, not cost. And when a number is going to drive a real decision, take a minute to recalculate it properly instead of trusting whatever figure turned up first.

Numbers don't need to be complicated to be useful. They just need to be right.

‍

Written by
BizAge Interview Team
November 19, 2026
Written by
November 19, 2026