What is altruistic surrogacy in Australia?

Altruistic surrogacy represents a life-changing pathway for many Australians hoping to start or expand their families. This compassionate arrangement allows a woman to carry and give birth to a child for another person or couple without receiving payment for her service. Altruistic surrogacy in Australia operates under strict legal frameworks that vary across states and territories, creating a complex landscape for intended parents and surrogates to navigate.

Key Takeaways

• Altruistic surrogacy is legal across Australia but commercial surrogacy is prohibited
• Legal requirements vary by state/territory with mandatory counselling and legal advice
• Only reasonable expenses can be reimbursed - no payment for the surrogacy service itself
• Parentage orders after birth transfer legal parenthood to the intended parents
• Both the surrogate and intended parents have specific eligibility requirements

What is altruistic surrogacy?

Altruistic surrogacy occurs when a woman (the surrogate) agrees to carry a pregnancy for another person or couple (the intended parents) without receiving payment for her service. The surrogate receives no financial gain beyond reimbursement for reasonable expenses directly related to the pregnancy.

This arrangement stands in stark contrast to commercial surrogacy, where the surrogate receives payment beyond expenses - a practice that remains illegal throughout Australia. The altruistic model emphasises the compassionate nature of surrogacy while aiming to prevent exploitation.

A typical altruistic surrogacy arrangement involves several key participants: the surrogate mother who carries the child, the intended parent(s) who will raise the child, potentially egg/sperm donors if needed, the medical team managing the pregnancy, and legal advisors ensuring compliance with relevant laws.

Australian legal framework

Surrogacy in Australia operates under a dual regulatory system. While the Commonwealth government oversees aspects like Medicare funding and international arrangements, each state and territory administers its own surrogacy legislation.

Despite variations between jurisdictions, several universal principles apply across Australia:

• Commercial surrogacy is prohibited nationwide
• Advertising for paid surrogacy is illegal
• The surrogate's informed consent is paramount
• All parties must receive independent legal advice
• Counselling is mandatory before proceeding
• Parentage transfer occurs after birth through court orders

The ban on commercial arrangements extends to advertising for paid surrogates or offering to be a paid surrogate. However, advertisements seeking altruistic surrogates or offering to be an altruistic surrogate are permitted in most jurisdictions with certain restrictions.

State-by-state rules

Each Australian state and territory maintains its own surrogacy legislation with unique requirements:

New South Wales: The Surrogacy Act 2010 requires a written surrogacy agreement before conception. Parentage orders can be applied for once the child is born, with the consent of all parties including the surrogate.

Victoria: Regulated by the Assisted Reproductive Treatment Act 2008, Victoria requires pre-approval from the Patient Review Panel, mandatory counselling, and registration of arrangements. Single people and same-sex couples can access surrogacy.

Queensland: The Surrogacy Act 2010 permits surrogacy for medical or social need. The surrogate must be at least 25 years old and have given birth previously. The intended parents must be Queensland residents.

"The most successful surrogacy arrangements we've seen involve clear communication, mutual respect, and thorough legal preparation between all parties involved." - Forte Family Law (https://fortefamilylawyers.com.au/)

Other jurisdictions: Western Australia permits surrogacy for heterosexual couples and single women with medical need; South Australia allows surrogacy for all couples and singles; Tasmania, the ACT and Northern Territory each have their own regulatory frameworks with varying eligibility requirements.

For the most current legislative information, always check the official government websites of the relevant state or territory.

Eligibility and consent

Surrogacy arrangements involve strict eligibility criteria for all participants:

Surrogate eligibility:

Most jurisdictions require the surrogate to:

- Be at least 25 years old (21 in some states)
- Have previously given birth to a child
- Be in good physical and psychological health
- Not be providing eggs for the pregnancy (gestational surrogacy)
- Provide informed consent

Intended parent eligibility:

Requirements vary by state but generally include:

- Medical or social need for surrogacy
- Residency within the state/territory
- Age restrictions (usually over 18)
- Relationship status varies (single, same-sex and heterosexual couples are eligible in most jurisdictions)

The informed consent process is rigorous, requiring all parties to understand the medical, legal, financial and emotional implications. This includes mandatory counselling sessions and obtaining independent legal advice before proceeding.

Costs and reimbursements

While commercial surrogacy is prohibited, the surrogate can receive reimbursement for reasonable expenses directly related to the pregnancy and birth. These typically include:

- Medical expenses not covered by Medicare or private health insurance
- Travel costs for medical appointments
- Maternity clothing
- Loss of income (if directly related to the pregnancy)
- Insurance premiums
- Counselling and legal costs

All expenses should be documented with receipts and included in the surrogacy agreement. While the surrogate cannot be paid for her service, the overall process involves significant costs for intended parents, including:

- IVF and fertility treatment (typically $10,000-$15,000 per cycle)
- Legal fees for surrogacy agreements and parentage orders (approximately $5,000-$15,000)
- Counselling services (around $1,000-$3,000)
- Medical expenses throughout pregnancy

Parental rights and birth registration

In Australian surrogacy arrangements, the surrogate (and her partner, if any) are initially considered the legal parents of the child. This remains the case until a parentage order transfers legal parenthood to the intended parents.

After birth, intended parents must apply to the relevant state court for a parentage order. Requirements typically include:

- The child is living with the intended parents
- All parties consent to the transfer of parentage
- The surrogacy arrangement was altruistic
- Counselling and legal requirements were met
- The application is made within a specified timeframe (usually 6 months to 1 year after birth)

Once granted, the parentage order allows the birth certificate to be amended, listing the intended parents as the child's legal parents. When donor gametes are used, additional legal considerations apply regarding the rights and responsibilities of donors.

Support resources

Those considering altruistic surrogacy should connect with specialised professionals and support networks:

Professional contacts:

- Fertility specialists with surrogacy experience
- Lawyers specialising in reproductive law
- Counsellors trained in surrogacy arrangements
- Hospitals with experience in surrogate births

Support organisations:

- Surrogacy Australia
- Australian Surrogacy Community
- State-specific support groups
- Online forums for intended parents and surrogates

Building a support network is invaluable throughout the surrogacy journey, providing practical advice and emotional backing during what can be a lengthy process.

Conclusion

Altruistic surrogacy offers a pathway to parenthood for Australians who cannot carry a pregnancy themselves. While legally complex and emotionally demanding, successful arrangements are possible when all parties approach the process with proper preparation and mutual respect.

For those considering surrogacy, the first step should be seeking specialist legal advice to understand the specific requirements in your state or territory. Forte Family Law recommends consulting with experienced surrogacy lawyers who can guide you through the legal complexities while helping protect the interests of everyone involved in this remarkable journey.

‍