Interview

Masterclass: SEO expert Simon Dalley explains Google and AI visibility

How to get your website noticed by search engines, including ChatGPT, Claude and other AIs
By
BizAge Interview Team
By

‍Hi Simon! Tell Us About Your Background in Search and SEO

I've worked in search for over twenty years now, which is a slightly frightening thing to admit.

I got into it the way a lot of people my age did. I was building websites and wanted to understand why some of them turned up in Google and others didn't. Nobody was really teaching SEO back then, so you learned by trying things and seeing what happened.

And I tried an awful lot of things. Some of them I wouldn't dream of doing now. I sometimes describe myself as a reformed spammer, and I'm only half joking.

I worked in digital marketing for several years, including at We Buy Any Car. Then the credit crunch hit, I was made redundant and we had a baby on the way. That made me think quite hard about how much control I had over my own future.

I set up GrowTraffic in Chorley in 2009 as a side business, around the time our son was born that October. I wanted to build something of my own, although I don't think I had any idea quite how much of my life it would eventually take over.

Seventeen years later we're based in Bacup in Rossendale, with a team working across Lancashire and South Yorkshire. We provide SEO, content marketing, PPC, websites and lead generation. I'm also a Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Marketing, which hopefully means I've learned a few things along the way.

More recently, I've been developing TrafficWonk, software that looks at how businesses appear in Google and AI-generated answers. It's a different set of problems from the ones I started out solving, but I find it just as interesting.

The thing that hasn't really changed is the question that got me interested in SEO in the first place. Why does one business get found and another doesn't?

The technology has changed enormously. I'm still trying to answer the same question.

For Beginners, How Do Businesses Achieve a Strong Google Ranking?

I think the first thing to understand is that there isn't a single trick that will suddenly get you to the top of Google.

There used to be quite a few tricks. Some worked really well. I know because I used them. But Google has spent years getting better at identifying the things people do purely to manipulate rankings, and building a business around those sorts of techniques is asking for trouble.

These days I'd concentrate on getting the basics right.

First, make it obvious what your business actually does.

That sounds ridiculously simple, but you'd be amazed how many websites don't manage it.

I've seen homepages with paragraphs about quality, professionalism and customer satisfaction without ever properly explaining what the company sells.

If somebody arrives on your website, they should be able to work out what you do, who you do it for and where you operate without having to hunt around.

Google needs to understand those things too.

Second, give your important services and products proper pages.

If you offer kitchen fitting, bathroom fitting and tiling, it's probably worth having a separate page for each service rather than expecting one page with a list to do all the work.

But don't create pages just to target slightly different keywords. Each page should have a useful purpose.

Explain what's involved, what it costs, how long it takes and what people should know before buying. Answer the questions customers actually ask you.

Third, make sure the website works properly.

It needs to load reasonably quickly, work on mobile phones and allow search engines to find and understand the important pages.

There are plenty of technical things you can do with SEO, but for a small business I'd start by making sure nothing important is broken.

There's not much point producing brilliant content if Google can't access it or customers give up because the website doesn't work.

Fourth, give people a reason to talk about your business.

Good reviews, mentions in local newspapers, involvement in your community and useful content that other websites genuinely want to reference can all help.

Links still matter, but I'd rather see a business earning a mention from somewhere relevant than buying links from websites nobody has ever heard of.

And finally, be patient.

Some changes can improve rankings quite quickly, particularly if you're fixing an obvious problem. But building a strong presence in search generally takes time.

The businesses that tend to do well are the ones that keep improving things rather than expecting three months of SEO to solve every problem they've got.

Ahrefs DR and Moz DA Are Commonly Cited as Useful Metrics for Measuring the Strength of a Domain. What's Your View of These Two?

They're useful, provided you understand what they're actually measuring.

Neither of them is a Google metric. Google doesn't use Ahrefs' Domain Rating or Moz's Domain Authority to decide where a website should rank.

They're scores produced by two different companies using their own data and calculations.

Ahrefs' DR is mainly concerned with the strength of a website's backlink profile. Moz's DA is designed to predict how likely a domain is to rank in search results.

They're useful for getting a general idea of how established a website might be or comparing it with competitors.

I use them myself.

The problem comes when people start treating the scores as an objective rather than an indicator.

As soon as somebody creates a number that people use to judge success, other people start finding ways to manipulate it.

I've seen websites with impressive Domain Ratings that get virtually no genuine traffic. They've accumulated large numbers of links, sometimes through fairly questionable methods, but the website itself has very little going for it.

As a reformed spammer, I recognise the pattern!

What I'd be more interested in is whether the website is relevant, whether it attracts genuine visitors and whether getting a mention or link from it would actually benefit the business.

If somebody offers you a backlink from a DR 70 website, that might sound impressive.

But if the website has nothing to do with your industry, doesn't get any meaningful traffic and exists largely to sell links, I'd question what you're really buying.

A high score doesn't automatically make a website valuable.

Is One Backlink From a Domain Enough? Or Do Multiple Links Multiply the Effect?

Generally, I'd rather have links from a wider range of relevant websites than lots of links from the same one.

But it's not quite as straightforward as counting referring domains.

The first link from a new website can be particularly useful because you're gaining a connection from a source that hasn't linked to you before.

However, a second or third link from that website could still be valuable, especially if it appears in a genuinely relevant article or points to a different part of your website.

You also have to consider where the link appears.

A link from a well-written article on a respected industry website is a different proposition from a link buried in somebody's footer.

And if that footer appears on ten thousand pages, it doesn't mean you've suddenly gained ten thousand valuable links.

Google has been dealing with repeated links like that for years.

I wouldn't try to put a precise multiplier on any of this because we don't know exactly how Google values individual links.

What I would say is that twenty links from twenty relevant websites would generally interest me more than twenty links from one website, assuming the quality was comparable.

It suggests that a wider range of people or organisations are referencing your business.

There's another way I like to think about backlinks.

Would a real person have a reason to click that link?

If somebody reads an article and follows a link to your website because it helps them understand something or find a useful product or service, that's the sort of link I'd want.

If the only reason it exists is to influence a metric in an SEO tool, I'd be rather more suspicious.

How Can Businesses Get Noticed by ChatGPT, Claude, and Other AI Platforms?

This is probably the question we're being asked most often at the moment.

A couple of years ago, hardly anybody was asking us what ChatGPT thought about their business. Now it's becoming a regular conversation.

The first thing I'd suggest is finding out what these systems are actually saying about you.

Open ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or whichever AI tools you want to investigate and ask the sorts of questions your customers might ask.

Who are the best companies providing your service in your area? Which businesses specialise in a particular product? What does your company do? How does it compare with competitors?

You might be surprised by the answers.

Sometimes they're reasonably accurate. Sometimes they're out of date. And sometimes they confidently tell you something that's completely wrong.

But don't make the mistake of checking once and assuming you've discovered your AI ranking.

You can ask the same question twice and get different answers. Results can vary depending on how you phrase the question, which system you're using and the context of the conversation.

There isn't one fixed set of AI rankings that everybody sees.

That's one of the reasons I've been developing TrafficWonk.

As for improving your chances of being mentioned or recommended, I'd start with some fairly familiar things.

Make sure your website clearly explains what you do. If you manufacture bespoke kitchen doors, provide specialist legal advice or work in a particular geographical area, make that information easy to find.

Publish information that comes from your actual experience. Your products, prices, processes, customer questions and examples of work you've completed are all things you know more about than a general information website.

Build a reputation beyond your own website. Genuine reviews, press coverage, relevant industry mentions and links can help establish what your business does and whether other people consider it worth recommending.

Keep your business information accurate and consistent. If different websites have contradictory information about your business, you're not making it any easier for people or AI systems to understand who you are.

The important thing is that a lot of this isn't all that different from good SEO.

We've spent years helping search engines understand businesses, their websites and their reputations. We're now having to think about how AI systems find and interpret that information as well.

There are differences, and we're still learning about them.

What I'd be particularly wary of is anybody promising to get your business recommended by ChatGPT within a week.

We've already got people trying to manipulate AI recommendations in the same way they used to manipulate Google.

I've been in the industry long enough to have a reasonable idea where that could end up.

Tell Us About the Software You Are Building So Businesses Can Appear in AI Answers

It's called TrafficWonk, and it came out of a problem we were increasingly encountering at GrowTraffic.

Clients were asking us what ChatGPT said about them, whether they were appearing in AI recommendations and how they compared with competitors.

The trouble is that we've spent years measuring visibility in Google using rankings, clicks and search traffic. With AI, it's a different situation.

Somebody can ask ChatGPT to recommend a business and receive a list of companies without ever visiting a search engine results page.

If your business is included, you might never know about it. If you're not included, you probably won't know that either.

And because the answers can change between requests, looking at a single response doesn't really tell you very much.

So we're developing TrafficWonk to help businesses understand where they're being found, how often they're appearing in AI-generated answers and how that changes over time.

It also looks at traditional search visibility because I don't think it makes sense to treat Google and AI as completely separate worlds.

One of the things we've learned while developing it is that measuring AI visibility properly is more complicated than taking a screenshot of a chatbot's answer.

You need to ask a range of relevant questions, repeat them and look at the patterns rather than assuming one answer represents what everybody sees.

And then there's the question of what a business should actually do with that information.

It's all very well telling somebody they don't appear in AI recommendations. That's not particularly useful unless you can help them understand what might be causing it and what they could improve.

That's a big part of what we're working towards.

It's still early, and I'm finding the development process itself really interesting.

A lot of the coding is now being done using AI tools. My job is increasingly to work out what the software needs to do, explain it and then establish whether what comes back actually works.

Which sounds considerably easier than it is.

How Should Companies Think About Budget, for SEO?

I'd start by looking at what a new customer is actually worth to the business.

Not just how much they spend, but how much profit the business makes from serving them and whether they're likely to come back.

If a customer generates several thousand pounds of profit over a few years, you can probably justify spending a reasonable amount to acquire them.

If you're making £20 profit from a one-off sale, you've got a rather different calculation to make.

It sounds obvious, but plenty of businesses choose their marketing budget by deciding what they feel comfortable spending rather than working out what they can afford to invest in acquiring customers.

I'd also think carefully about how long you're prepared to commit.

SEO isn't the same as buying advertising. With PPC, you can start a campaign and potentially begin generating enquiries almost immediately, although whether they're profitable is another question.

With SEO, you're generally building something that takes time to develop.

You might see improvements in the first few weeks, particularly if there are technical problems to fix, but more competitive markets can take considerably longer.

If you've only got enough money to fund three months of SEO and you need customers next week, I'd probably suggest looking at other ways to generate enquiries first.

I'd also be cautious about very cheap SEO packages.

If somebody is offering to do all your SEO for £99 a month, I'd want to know exactly what they're going to do.

There's nothing wrong with a small business spending a modest amount on occasional improvements. But comprehensive SEO involves time, expertise and quite a lot of work.

At £99 a month, there's a limit to how much of that you're realistically going to receive.

At the other end, spending thousands doesn't automatically mean you're getting better results.

The important thing is understanding what needs doing, what it's likely to cost and whether there's a reasonable commercial case for doing it.

And you should be measuring the results against what matters to your business.

Rankings and traffic are useful things to monitor, but at the end of the day most businesses need enquiries, customers and sales.

What Are the Classic Errors Companies Make When Trying to Improve Their SEO and AI Visibility?

I could probably write a book about this, although I'm not sure anybody would want to read it.

There are a few things that come up again and again.

Chasing traffic rather than customers.

I named my agency GrowTraffic, so I'm aware of the irony.

But traffic was never really the point. It's what you want people to do once they've found your website that matters.

I've seen businesses double their organic traffic without generating any more enquiries because the additional visitors weren't looking for anything the business actually sold.

Producing content because a keyword research tool says you should.

We've all done it. Find a keyword with a reasonable search volume, write an article about it and hope it ranks.

But if the article says exactly the same thing as every other website, what have you really achieved?

That's becoming an even bigger issue now that AI systems can answer many straightforward questions without sending somebody to a website.

I'd rather see a business publish something useful based on its own experience than another fifty articles repeating information that's already available everywhere else.

Making customers work too hard to find information.

If somebody wants to know roughly what you charge, where you operate or whether you can help with their particular problem, make it easy for them.

You'd be amazed how many websites hide the very information somebody needs to make a buying decision.

Buying links purely to manipulate rankings.

I did plenty of that sort of thing earlier in my career.

And the uncomfortable bit is that some of those techniques worked. Some continued working for quite a long time.

But you're building your search visibility around something that Google is actively trying to identify and discount.

When it stops working, or when a website gets into trouble because of it, putting things right can be expensive.

I'd much rather invest in something that has value beyond manipulating search results.

Changing everything at once.

A business decides it needs a new website, changes the design, rewrites all the content and alters every page address.

Then its Google rankings fall and nobody knows which change caused the problem.

I'm not suggesting businesses shouldn't improve their websites. But if you're making significant changes, plan them properly and understand the SEO implications before you start.

Believing anybody who guarantees results.

Nobody can guarantee you'll rank first in Google for a competitive keyword or that ChatGPT will recommend your business.

There are simply too many things outside anybody's control.

If somebody is making those promises, I'd want to understand how they intend to deliver them.

And finally, giving up too soon.

SEO can be frustrating because improvements don't always produce immediate results.

You might spend months working on something before you start seeing the benefit.

But I've also seen businesses abandon a strategy just as things were beginning to improve because they expected everything to happen much more quickly.

That doesn't mean you should keep spending money indefinitely on something that isn't working.

It means you need realistic expectations and a way of measuring whether you're making progress.

How Can Businesses Work With You, if They Need a Boost to Their Online Digital Profile?

The easiest way is to get in touch through our website at growtraffic.co.uk or give us a ring.

We've been helping businesses improve their visibility online since 2009, working with companies across a range of industries.

We cover SEO, content marketing, PPC, website development and lead generation, although these days an increasing amount of our work also involves understanding how AI is changing the way people find businesses.

What interests me is how all these things work together.

There's not much point ranking well in Google if the people arriving on your website aren't interested in what you're selling. Equally, there's limited value in appearing in AI recommendations if that visibility isn't contributing to the business in some way.

We want to help businesses get found by the right people and turn that visibility into something commercially useful.

We'll normally start by looking at where a business is now, what's working, what isn't and what might be holding it back.

Sometimes the answer is SEO. Sometimes it's PPC, the website itself or a combination of things.

And occasionally the answer is that the business needs to sort something else out before spending money on marketing.

I'd much rather have that conversation at the beginning than take somebody's money for something I don't think is going to work.

‍

Written by
BizAge Interview Team
November 21, 2026
Written by
November 21, 2026